Motivational interviewing as a coaching technique
Motivational interviewing is a method to improve patients’ motivation and to ensure that they follow the course of treatment as recommended [5]. Motivational interviewing uses certain key principles: collaborate with the patient, investigate what is going on with the patient and connect with it and suppress the reflex to give advice straight away. It can be used as part of behavioural change. People are often ambivalent about change: they simultaneously do and do not want to change. The word ‘but’ is a sign of ambivalence (I know I have to lose weight, but I hate exercising). Healthcare providers are often in favour of change, and they will try to convince the person that it is the best way forward. Then the patient will often start defending the other side and ultimately talk him- or herself out of changing. This creates resistance – the person might start arguing with you or deny that there is a problem at all. It is better to try to elicit change talk which is the opposite of resistance. Change talk is made up of statements about the desire or reasons for change. When you hear yourself talking about reasons for change, that increases your motivation. It is important to strengthen/empower change talk. There are six types of change talk: desire (I want...), ability (I could...), reason (I would probably feel better if I...), need (I need to...), commitment (I am going to...) and taking steps (this week I started...). When trying to elicit change talk, you can first ask about the pros and cons of the current situation and then about the pros and cons of change. Below we describe some conversation techniques you can use in your motivational interviewing. These techniques are followed by two videos. The first video is an example of a coaching session that does not use motivational interviewing, and the second shows motivational interviewing being used in a correct way.
Conversation techniques for motivational interviewing
There are some important conversation techniques for motivational interviewing. A distinction can be made between general techniques and specific techniques. General techniques are asking open questions, listening, reflecting, summarising and giving information, while specific techniques include eliciting change talk and using a scale to ask about someone’s motivation. These techniques are discussed below.
General techniques
Asking open questions
- You will often elicit more information if you ask open questions.
- Try not to fall into a pattern of questions and answers, where you ask a lot of (closed) questions that someone then answers. Try to get the person to tell you what they want to say, by asking open questions.
Listening
- Listening can help you gain information and improve your relationship with a person.
- You can use an open question to invite the person to speak, so you can then listen to what the person says.
- Silences are useful, and small inviting reactions such as ‘Yes, yes’ or ‘Hm, hm’ can also help.
Reflecting
- Reflecting is, after you have listened to what a person says, repeating what was said in the form of a statement (not a question), such as ‘So you are not feeling great’. The person will often be encouraged to go on to talk more, which means you can do more listening.
- You can reflect resistance and change talk using a statement like: ‘You feel that the program could really help you’.
Summarising
- A summary is a way of looking back at the conversation, or part of the conversation, and getting to the heart of the matter.
- Giving a summary shows that you have listened and gives you the opportunity to check whether you missed anything. If necessary, you can then go on to change the direction of the conversation.
- Try to use change talk in your summary.
Giving information
- Finally, you can give information; you should ask permission before doing this. Find out what the person needs.
- You could offer options and talk about what other people have done.
- Do not give too much information, and make sure you take a positive tone.
Specific techniques
- You can ask questions that elicit change talk (e.g. ‘What do you want most?’ or ‘What could you do?’).
- You can also work on the decisional balance. That is: discuss the pros and cons of the current situation and the pros and cons of the proposed change (e.g. ‘What are the benefits/costs of changing?’). Ask first about the benefits of the current situation and the costs of the change, then ask about the costs of the current situation and the benefits of the change. Herewith you stimulate the person to start using change talk. E.g. ‘What would be the costs of doing an exercise in the program, and what would be the benefits of doing an exercise?’
- You can also ask direct questions about the person’s motivation, using a scale: ‘On a scale of 1 to 10, how motivated are you to change?’ Or: ‘On a scale of 1 to 10, how far have you already come towards making a change?’ Then you could ask why the person did not give a lower score, and what would need to happen for the score to go up. The change talk will follow from there. E.g. ‘On a scale of 1 to 10, how motivated are you to start doing an exercise?’
- You can also ask about the next step: ask what the person wants to do now, or is planning to do (e.g. ‘What do you want to do?’).
- You can also use hypothetical language if the person does not seem to be keen on changing yet (e.g. ‘If you would decide to...’).
Motivational interviewing during coaching
Always conduct the conversations in the spirit of motivational interviewing. That means that you try to enter into the participant’s experience, that you maintain a cooperative attitude and that you always show understanding in the face of resistance. The general techniques you can use to do this are: asking open questions, listening carefully, and occasionally reflecting and summarising. What you must not do is adopt a lecturing tone or try to persuade the person. You can also use more specific motivational interviewing techniques during the coaching session. These techniques can be really helpful if participants are not doing their exercises regularly, for instance. Something you could do in that situation is to ask about the pros and cons of doing the exercises. That can be a good way to elicit statements that cause people to do the exercises more regularly.
Sample videos
There are two videos below. The first video is an example of a coaching session that does not use motivational interviewing, and the second shows motivational interviewing being used in the right way. You will need to enter a password to watch the videos. In both cases the password is: el-coach.